Hey @re-animatedCat, I spoke with my homeowners insurance, AAA about this. It's kinda goofy. He said I could get a rider for my records but the max it would cover was $10,000, (which doesn't cover the value of the collection). He also said they'd have to be appraised individually, which is just ridiculous.
However, if you have the contents of your home insured, they are covered anyway. This includes fire, theft, natural disaster, etc. So, just make sure your home contents coverage payout is enough to cover your collection as well as your other items.
I'm sure this varies according to which provider you have. I'm in the states, so there might be different policies if you are in a different country as we'll.
The thought of losing your collection is just depressing as no amount of money can replace the time or effort it took to compile, and many can't be found again easily.
I'm gonna go hug my records now and tell them I love them